The verdict has finally been handed down: there will be no universal suffrage in 2012.
The Standing Committee of China’s National People’s Congress (NPC) has voted not to allow Hong Kong citizens to elect their own chief executive and legislators in 2012. The decision is disappointing, but not entirely unpredictable or surprising. This is the second time the NPC has dashed the hope for full elections in Hong Kong. In 2004, the NPC vetoed a proposal to let Hong Kong citizens elect the chief executive by universal suffrage in 2007.
Included in the verdict is a vague promise that the NPC may consider granting universal suffrage in 2017, for the election of the fifth Hong Kong Chief Executive, provided that a bill of amendment to the election method, to be submitted by the Hong Kong Chief Executive and endorsed by two-thirds majority of all the members of the Hong Kong Legislative Council, would be deemed acceptable by the NPC.
As pointed out by Hong Kong based blogger Tom Legg: “If you take the spin from the Chief Executive and NPC members at face value, then Hong Kong has been granted greater democracy. On the other hand, thinking people would understand the devil is in the details of the implementation.”






